Carolina Panthers sends:
Rayford Ho (CB)
James Berg (WLB)
1982 Round 1 Selection 3

Miami Dolphins sends:
Andres Scholz (MLB)
Jason Morrow (WLB)
1982 Round 1 Selection 26 (Miami Dolphins)
1984 Round 1 (Miami Dolphins)


(This is an automated message. If you believe this trade warrants additional investigation, please contact the league admin.)

This trade is under review.

Do Not move any of the assets involved in this trade until the review is posted. That will be within 24hrs.

This trade has been rejected

Votes:
Accepted 0
Rejected 2
Abstain 1

Forgot: This will not count against the trade restriction.

Explain please? Ho isn't worth a late 1st? 1.3 and Berg isn't worth 1.26, Morrow, and Scholz? Like are y'all vetoing all these trades because they're completely lopsided, franchise destroying trades or is it simply because y'all wouldn't make these deals? Might as well review the Buffalo trade in which he basically got ripped off... A decent RB, 2nd, and 3rd for a 29 year old TE and a depth DT? I respect the process of review, but at this point, geez. Just seems like there's some owners that are colluding to try prevent me from improving my team. I get it, my trade with NYG definitely leaned my way, but my trade with Baltimore was fair yet it was reviewed anyways. NONE of those trades were formed through collusion or were franchise destroying trades. These owners know what they want. NYG wanted Tilghman ever since last year but we couldn't trade due to the 2 trade rule. He was still interested this year. Baltimore put those players on the block, anyone could've beat the offer I sent to them. Miami wanted a top tier CB and was interested in getting back into the draft. I sent him an offer that allowed him to do so. Yes, some of those players were old, but those teams knew what they were getting. My team is being punished due to my wheeling and dealing style because the rest of the league is too inept to send them deals that help them improve their team the way they want to.

I’ll admit that I did request a review on a previous trade, but I agree with Carolina 100% on this one. This trade should’ve passed.

I kinda liked it depending on where Miami's 84 1st rounder ends up. But that's the gamble in this trade. I really like Ho and the #3 pick is a good thing.

I didnt realize Ho was in his 8th year already. That changes my view then. But this deal is re-workable for sure.

How Paydirt's GMs act everytime jouameng makes a trade



Just kidding, but I agree with what jouameng said. I feel like some owners are a bit harsh with him. This trade should’ve passed imo.

No comment from the dolphins organization

lmao

I guess I just think differently the trade looks way lopsided to me. looks like Miami is taking all the financial risk for an older player they may or may not be able to resign and an average Shmo with less than average stats. The star of this side in the 1st round #3 VS. two players with high potential and 4-5 years left for short money and 2 #1 picks a 24th and an unknown...
looks lopsided to me....I did not ask for this review. I did vote to reject it.

Now as far as collusion among the competition committee I have to object. I hate to see someone get beat...like I did when I started until I understood how the game worked. I have seen players get beat by the best of them....Gm's who's jock strap your not fit to wear...I have had run ins with all of them. they all say the same thing what/ I can't build my team.......Personally, I don't care what you do or how you play your game. Knock yourself out dude...I am on the competition committer and part of that is to rule on trades. I vote my concience and your right my style or mindset IS different so yes I disagree with some of your tactics ..but don't accuse anyone of colluding without proof. Now that you have stomped your feet and made fun of the grown ups..go rework an even trade that the current CC will approve.
I don't have any bad feelings towards you...I actually PM'd mitch today and I think I spoke pretty highly of you....Good luck in your future trades sir........................................MM