Carolina Panthers sends:
1976 Round 1
1977 Round 1
1978 Round 1

San Francisco 49ers sends:
Thomas Jobe (TE)
Fidel Phillips (CB)


(This is an automated message. If you believe this trade warrants additional investigation, please contact the league admin.)

Really? 3 first rd picks for a TE? To each their own

Yet all my trades get the vote treatment...

just request a review guys

trade review underway

Note: Remember when a review is underway do not move involved assets (picks/players) under this trade clears.

More Carolina controversy!!!

trade denied 2-1.

Trade does not count towards either teams trade limit. And GM's can work on it some more and re-submit if they choose.

And it's been a quiet year for them so far. lol
I really admire how both Carolina and Seattle built their championship teams through a lot of trading. That takes some skill to make it all work out in the end. Especially since we have a trade limit and a trade review process when requested. Can't blame it on predatory trading. Just good ole fashion wheelin n dealin. Been fun to watch the different ways teams are building.

For the record, I have no problem with the trade, it's between two GM's who have been around. I think it's one sided, but to each their own. I thought it was more one sided than the three trades I've had be reviewed, which was my only point. To me the reviews are for new GM's who may be taken advantage of, not a GM who just won the title.

Any GM can request a trade review on any trade.

I don't want you guys to feel bad to request a review and dont want you to be mad if one of your trades gets a request. Just have fun with the whole thing.