The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - League News/General Discussion

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By setherick
7/19/2017 6:49 pm
blackflys wrote:
Why would you question him voiding it?


This. Just this.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston

By blackflys
7/19/2017 6:50 pm
For sure and it don't bother me as much as my post might make it seem like but the trade is suspect to say the least.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By Beercloud
7/19/2017 6:53 pm
If the trade balance system is making it tough for you guys to work something out let me know.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By blackflys
7/19/2017 6:54 pm
e
Last edited at 7/19/2017 6:55 pm

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By jouameng
7/19/2017 7:17 pm
I'm not saying it's suspect, I'm saying they should be held accountable for their trades. They're both young owners and they need to learn what trades to make and what not to make. The only concern I seriously would have is if Campton were to leave after this season. It'd definitely handicap the new owner of Tennessee for the next few seasons. Otherwise Campton has to stick with the deal and build his team other ways. I personally think that they need to learn from their mistakes instead of voiding their trades over and over again until they finally get it "right", something that owners would even differ on. Just because they've been on MFN for only a month doesn't mean they should have to wait a little longer to understand trading. They need to learn by making trades. Not by watching other teams make trades. I'd be more agreeable with the void if Houston offered it but it was Tennessee that sent the offer. Each owner builds their team differently with a different objective. Unless there is absolute clear collusion I don't think the trade should've been voided.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By chinaski
7/19/2017 7:43 pm
Im ok with the veto, the trade is massively unbalanced.

But the most alarming thing to me is they both joined the site on the very same day. This isnt a high volume site... joining the same day and joining the same league....c'mon now.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By jouameng
7/19/2017 7:47 pm
From what I see they joined a day apart. If you were to look deeper this is the only league they have in common. Highly doubt it was collusion.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By chinaski
7/19/2017 7:54 pm
Says they both joined on 6/6 for me. As far as only having one league in common, this could be the first attempt at joining the same league, same division even. Id have JDB do an IP check just in case.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By jouameng
7/19/2017 7:57 pm
I don't understand how they'd be able to trade if they had the same IP as you can only trade after 30 days of the same IP... With Houston still in all their leagues, meaning they weren't kicked for inactivity, I find it hard to see that they're colluding.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Houston Texans

By blackflys
7/19/2017 8:49 pm
Highly doubt they are a collusion? What more suspicious behavior do you need to start believing that this does happen on this game and sometimes you get new guys who don't realize how easy it can be to figure it out. Joined same day and made one of the worst trades I have witnessed since I have started. The trade makes no sense at all other then for one team to load up on pics.