New Sticky Note

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - League News/General Discussion

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Androwski
3/15/2020 3:52 pm
Mcarovil wrote:
Bart Butler did pretty good for us. Just too many and he was a numbers cut.

Maybe I’ll bring him back.

If this trade bothers you then maybe throw the challenge flag?

I already did. Just wanted to show why 'there are not other options' reason doesn't make sense

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Beercloud
3/15/2020 4:19 pm
We have a Review Request via pm. I will send out the request ballot to the CC.
Both teams please freeze the assets in this trade until the review is over within 24 hrs.

Note: Currently this completes the trade restriction between Tennessee and Chicago.
If the trade is rejected by the CC it will not count towards the restriction.

Last edited at 3/15/2020 4:32 pm

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By dd35
3/15/2020 4:34 pm
Beercloud wrote:
We have a Review Request via pm. I will send out the request ballot to the CC.
Both teams please freeze the assets in this trade until the review is over within 24 hrs.

Note: Currently this completes the trade restriction between Tennessee and Chicago.
If the trade is rejected by the CC it will not count towards the restriction.



lol

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Androwski
3/15/2020 4:48 pm
dd35 wrote:
lol

???

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By dd35
3/15/2020 4:56 pm
This fair trade thing seems to be a very fluid concept in this league. Multiple deals this offseason have been structured in a very similar fashion as this one, but haven't been challenged. We are all trying to make a deal that is best for our team, as was the case for this (so I'm sure the deal will stand), but what is your reasoning to challenging it?

Both owners are content with what they received in the deal, I didn't deceive Damion in any way when I sent the offer. I recognized his team was weak in the running game last year, so I sent an offer for a RB that I no longer needed because I signed one in Free Agency

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By marinarul10
3/15/2020 5:02 pm
dd35 wrote:
but what is your reasoning to challenging it?

, so I sent an offer for a RB that I no longer needed because I signed one in Free Agency


You just answer it, if your RB is worse than an FA is not worth a 2nd round pick....

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By dd35
3/15/2020 5:05 pm
marinarul10 wrote:
dd35 wrote:
but what is your reasoning to challenging it?

, so I sent an offer for a RB that I no longer needed because I signed one in Free Agency


You just answer it, if your RB is worse than an FA is not worth a 2nd round pick....


I signed the FA in Week 1 of FA. I kept the traded RB on my roster for depth but no longer needed him when I found a gem of a WR in the 7th round who can play RB for me. So the guy I traded away was going to sit as my 3rd/ 4th string RB. I wasn't ever going to eat the dead cap and cut him unless I traded him

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Beercloud
3/15/2020 5:10 pm
dd35
This fair trade thing seems to be a very fluid concept in this league.


Any GM or myself can request a review.
Doesn't mean a trade is auto rejected or accepted. The CC will vote on it.

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Mcarovil
3/15/2020 5:20 pm
That’s not exactly accurate. There are lots of players in FA 1 who have talent. If he signed him after FA and late FA your statement would be true.

10 other teams bid on said RB so I would wager he was valued higher than a 2.


Plus he shouldn’t have to defend himself in a public forum. trade reviews can be a slippery slope if it gets out of control.
marinarul10 wrote:
dd35 wrote:
but what is your reasoning to challenging it?

, so I sent an offer for a RB that I no longer needed because I signed one in Free Agency


You just answer it, if your RB is worse than an FA is not worth a 2nd round pick....
Last edited at 3/15/2020 5:23 pm

Re: Completed Trade: Tennessee Titans and Chicago Bears

By Damion
3/15/2020 7:42 pm
I will wait
Last edited at 3/15/2020 7:44 pm