The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - League News/General Discussion

Re: Rules Debate

By jgcruz
5/21/2020 2:16 pm
We did not vote to suspend the rule relative to when a rule may be adopted. Hence, the proposed new rule will NOT go into effect.

If there is is desire after this season to implement the rule, i.e., someone proposes the rule and it gets a second and third, we'll reconsider it and/or some other proposal next season.

Thank you.

Re: Rules Debate

By Meatmen
5/21/2020 3:44 pm
Then let the games begin gentleman Yay!!!!!#
Last edited at 5/21/2020 3:44 pm

Re: Rules Debate

By dd35
5/21/2020 3:57 pm
jgcruz wrote:
We did not vote to suspend the rule relative to when a rule may be adopted. Hence, the proposed new rule will NOT go into effect.

If there is is desire after this season to implement the rule, i.e., someone proposes the rule and it gets a second and third, we'll reconsider it and/or some other proposal next season.

Thank you.


Since Beercloud left, there has been no rules sticky forum. I feel like we should put it back in place so new owners to the league understand everything going on

Re: Rules Debate

By jgcruz
5/21/2020 4:36 pm
dd35 wrote:
jgcruz wrote:
We did not vote to suspend the rule relative to when a rule may be adopted. Hence, the proposed new rule will NOT go into effect.

If there is is desire after this season to implement the rule, i.e., someone proposes the rule and it gets a second and third, we'll reconsider it and/or some other proposal next season.

Thank you.


Please show me where it is and I'll sticky it. Thanks.

Since Beercloud left, there has been no rules sticky forum. I feel like we should put it back in place so new owners to the league understand everything going on

Re: Rules Debate

By dd35
5/21/2020 6:35 pm
I have looked and cant find it. But that's my point, we keep talking about rules, when there are no rules stated in the forums

Re: Rules Debate

By jgcruz
5/22/2020 5:29 pm
Can anyone help find it?

Re: Rules Debate

By awest827
5/22/2020 11:47 pm
A) Make a proposal

B) After a proposal gets a second and a third from different GM's it will go up for all league GM's to vote on it.

C) One GM one vote, majority rules.

D) Proposals are accepted after Pre-Season game 1 and before Week 15 of the regular season.

E) Voting will take place from Wild Card weekend til the off-week right before the Super Bowl.

F) This thread is for rule proposals and second and thirds only. (No debating or discussions)

G) Debating will be done in the Rules Debate thread to keep this thread clean.

F) Proposals will be up for vote for 7 calender days before being closed.



A. Any GM not logging into MFN within the last 7 days would receive a "Activity Warning" pm from the league Commissioner or Head of Football Operations.

1. The GM will have 48 hrs to respond his activity intent.

1.1) If the GM does not respond in time they will be fired from the team.
1.1a) They will be eligible to return to the league through the waiting list system as long as they are in good standing.

1.2) If the GM responds within 48 hrs he will keep his job.
1.2a) If the GM responds within 48hrs and their intent is deemed unacceptable it goes to the Competition Committee for a vote to retain the GM or to Fire the GM.


Paydirt Hall of Fame


Requirements:
Player must be retire and are eligible the following year.
Must meet at least 1 min. requirement for their position or misc category for nomination.
Meeting min requirement does not guarantee a place on the ballot.

Voting Procedure:
a) Hall of Fame Committee will consist of AFC Rep, NFC Rep, Head of Football Operation, PR Director and Commissioner.
b) HoF committee will nominate players from Wild Card Weekend til the End of Season stage.
c) Each HoF committee member may nominate as many as two players and 1 GM per year.
d) After each member has turned in their nominees, a ballot of those players will be presented to the leagues GM's for a general vote.
e) General vote will take place between Early FA 1 and Early FA 5.
f) The top 3 players and 1 GM with votes will be inducted into the Paydirt Hall of Fame.
g) Hall of Fame class will be announced during Pre-Season Week 1.
h) There is no limit to the amount of times a player or GM can be nominated.

*************************************************************************************************************
*************************************************************************************************************

Min. Guidelines:

GMs:
150 wins
3 Super Bowls
1st Super Bowl winner guaranteed (no voting)

QB
35,000 yds+
300 TDs
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

RB:
10,000 yds
50 rush TDs
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

WR:
10,000 yds
70 TDs
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

TE:
7,500 yds
35 TDs
5 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

OL:
5,000 pass blocks
5,000 run blocks
5 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

DL:
150 sacks
500 hurries
300 tackles
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

LB:
700 tackles
100 sacks
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

DB:
45 Int
200 knock downs
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

K:
400 FG
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

P:
50,000 yds punting
200 inside the 20
10 player of the weeks
3 player of the years
5 time All Pro

Misc:
100 total TDs
10 Kickoff Returns
10 Punt Returns
30 Forced Fumbles



Team owners aren't allowed to trade away all three of their 1st round picks in a single season. The exception being that they own another 1st round pick within those 3 years, which then becomes untradeable.




AFC GM's will vote for the AFC Rep and NFC GM's will vote on their NFC Rep. One GM one vote rule. Each Rep will join the League Commissioner on the committee.

Job Description:
1) Will vote on proposals presented to them by the leagues GM's.
a) Deadline for rule proposals will be week 3. (with exception of 1970. Rule proposal deadline will be week 9)
b) Voting will take place at the trade deadline. (with exception of 1970. Voting will take place on week 12)
c) All rules passed will take effect no sooner than the following season or beyond if that's what was proposed.
2) Recruiting of new GM's to fill open spots.
3) Approving of new GM requests.
4) setting disciplinary actions guidelines for rules broken.
5) answering GM grievances from their respective conferences.
6) will help rookie from your conference. Answering their question and giving guidance.



There may be other rules that I couldn't find I know another one is you can only trade with the same team twice per season. Another one is no tanking.

Re: Rules Debate

By jgcruz
5/23/2020 1:07 am
Great job, awest.

Re: Rules Debate

By Androwski
11/11/2020 4:10 pm
Now that we have some time before the season ends... how are you guys feeling about adding more weight restrictions?

Just saw this rule in other league and I think it would be interesting to start a discussion about it:

QB 2 (No # limit)
RB 3-4 (minimum 200#)
FB/TE 3-3 (minimum 240#)
WR 4-6 (No # limit)
OL 10-12 (C min 260#/G&T min 290#)
K/P 2 (No limit)
DL 8-9 (DE min 265 #/DT min 290#)
LB 8-9 (min 237 #)
DB 9-10 (No # limit)

Re: Rules Debate

By marinarul10
11/12/2020 8:28 am
Imo there is no need for all this rules, we will not be able to follow them and only DL can make a difference